Flipping America 275, Scott Murphy, Real Estate Appraisals

podcast 275 Real estate Appraisals with Scott Murphy


Quick question: What is a property worth? Answer: What someone is willing to pay for it. That answer is truthful, but it doesn’t always end up being “correct.” That’s because few people pay cash for real estate. When you borrow money the lender is going to protect their interests by ordering an appraisal. 

They will contact a licensed appraiser who will examine the property, compare it to nearby similar properties for sale or that have been sold, and will prepare a report that reflects his or her opinion of value. Although it is an opinion, it carries weight with the lender. In fact the lender will almost completely disregard what the buyer is willing to pay for the property if the appraiser has a different opinion.

This makes the appraiser an important piece of the puzzle. And it’s a piece over which you have no control. I was in this business when we could still choose an appraiser and I watched them get pressured into justifying higher prices than should have been reasonable. Since the collapse of 2008 and the passage of Dodd-Frank, appraisers are now selected from a blind pool by the lender and no one in the process is allowed to pressure or influence the appraiser. Although this system has its flaws, it’s probably better than the previous. 

So you’re going to have an appraiser and this piece is outside your control. It would be a good idea if you knew what an appraiser was thinking before you BOUGHT the property right? That’s what we are going to do for you today. We are going to help you get inside the mind of an appraiser. 

Scott Murphy is joining us in a few minutes. Mr. Murphy has been appraising real estate since 1985. In 1993 he earned his SRA designation from the Appraisal Institute – a credential earned by less than 1% of the appraiser population.

In 1996 he established D. S. Murphy & Associates and has grown the firm to have over 70 associates – servicing Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Florida and California.

In 2004, Mr. Murphy was appointed by Gov Perdue to the Georgia Real Estate Appraisers Board where he is actively working to improve the laws and more closely regulate appraisers in Georgia. He has served as the Chairman of the Georgia Real Estate Appraisers Board for the past four years.

He is an active member of the Appraisal Institute, the National Associates of Realtors, the Northeast Metro Atlanta Board of Realtors and the Georgia Real Estate Fraud Prevention and Awareness Coalition.

Also coming up – it might be getting harder for your buyers to get a loan. And I have unbelievable news about recent home sales. They are both up AND down. I’ll have the coverage and explain shortly. And folks this is as close as we get to genuine hilarity in the world of real estate so decide now you’re just going to laugh about it with me. 

And Ben Carson is working on affordable housing. I’ll have that story today also.

How to contact us



Twitter and Instagram @FlippingAmerica

Call our National Comment Line: 404-369-1018, ext 1. Leave your message or your question. 

Email your questions to questions@rogerblankenship.com. Please always tell us where you are from. We like to know where the show is being heard. And let us know how you found out about us if you don’t mind. 

Guest: Scott Murphy




  • Lunch with me every Wednesday. Baraonda
  • My latest article in Forbes is out. bit.ly/findredeals.
  • The FAN is here!
  • Would you like to invest in the Flipping America projects across the country? Coming soon you will be able to for as little as $100. That’s right, Flipping America is partnering with Ground Floor Funding to create a crowd-funded platform where you can invest in the deals we are doing here. The fund will pay out a 8% preferred rate of return and can go as high as 16%. You can make money with me, the Flipping America Guy. 
  • Flipping America App is in the app store. You can listen to the show, read the show notes, and the entire catalog of shows is now available to you. It’s a free download and there are no upsells or in-app purchases. Free to download, free to listen. Go ahead and give it a try and drop me a line and let me know what you think.
  • Want a quick analytical tool to tell you how strong a potential fix and flip deal is? Download the Property Grade app. You answer 10 simple questions about the property and the app instantly tells you what you can expect to make, your return on investment, your return on cash, and then the program gives the project a letter grade using the proprietary Flipping America Investment Property Grade algorithm.  


Your Questions: Send emails to questions@rogerblankenship.com

Comment Line calls and Questions

Call 404-369-1018, press 1 and leave your message!

Motivational Thoughts for the day

  • “A thousand candles can be lit from the light of one candle and life of the candle will not be shortened. Happiness will never be decreased by being shared.” – Buddha

Expected Air Date: 8/11/19

Scott Murphy

Leave a Reply